« Back to Results

The Impact of Chinese Trade: The Good, The Bad and the Apocryphal

Paper Session

Saturday, Jan. 5, 2019 10:15 AM - 12:15 PM

Atlanta Marriott Marquis, A602
Hosted By: American Economic Association
  • Chair: Robert Feenstra, University of California-Davis

New Perspectives on the Decline of United States Manufacturing Employment

Teresa C. Fort
,
Dartmouth College
Justin Pierce
,
Federal Reserve Board
Peter Schott
,
Yale University

Abstract

We use relatively unexplored dimensions of US microdata to examine how US manufacturing employment has evolved across industries, firms, establishments, and regions from 1977 to 2012. We show that these data provide support for both trade- and technology-based explanations of the overall decline of employment over this period, and that US trade with China seems especially relevant after 2000. Our results also highlight the difficulties of estimating the distinct contributions of trade versus technology in the aggregate decline. Toward that end, we discuss how further analysis of these trends might yield sharper insights.

The Impact of Chinese Trade: The Good, The Bad and the Apocryphal

Nicholas Bloom
,
Stanford University
Kyle Handley
,
University of Michigan
Andre Kurman
,
Drexel University
Philip Luck
,
University of Colorado-Denver

Abstract

We study the effects of China’s growing importance in global trade on U.S. employment dynamics during the quarter century from 1990-2015. Using U.S. Census microdata we decompose employment growth into job creation and destruction at births, deaths and continuing establishments within local labor markets. First, we confirm the main findings of a negative impact on manufacturing in Autor et al. (2013) for the 1990s and early 2000s. But, we also find strong evidence of positive employment growth and readjustment towards services and non-manufacturing sectors in more recent years. Second, a large share of the manufacturing job losses comes from establishments exiting from manufacturing. But remarkably, the shift toward non-manufacturing jobs is heavily driven by manufacturing plants switching into non-manufacturing activities, explaining the drop in manufacturing and simultaneous rise in non-manufacturing employment. Third, we document a large increase in labor market turbulence in response to the China shock, with job reallocation rates surging in response to Chinese import penetration as local labor markets transform and adjust.

When Work Disappears: Manufacturing Decline and the Falling Marriage Market Value of Young Men

David Autor
,
Massachusetts Institute of Technology
David Dorn
,
University of Zurich
Gordon Hanson
,
University of California-San Diego

Abstract

We exploit the gender-specific components of large-scale labor demand shocks stemming from rising international manufacturing competition to test how shifts in the relative economic stature of young men versus young women affected marriage, fertility and children’s living circumstances during 1990-2014. On average, trade shocks differentially reduce employment and earnings of young adult males. Consistent with Becker’s model of household specialization, shocks to male’s relative earnings reduce marriage and fertility. Consistent with prominent sociological accounts, these shocks heighten male idleness and premature mortality, and raise the share of mothers who are unwed and the share of children living in below-poverty, single-headed households.

Magnification of the 'China Shock' Through the United States Housing Market

Robert Feenstra
,
University of California-Davis
Hong Ma
,
Tsinghua University
Yuan Xu
,
Tsinghua University

Abstract

We re-examine the findings of Autor, Dorn, and Hanson (American Economic Review, 2013), on the impact of Chinese import penetration on U.S. local employment while taking into account the concurrent housing boom and subsequent bust. We find that fluctuations the local housing market amplified the impact of import penetration for China. Regions that experienced greater import competition also had a smaller rise or greater fall in housing price, with the associated impact on employment in the construction industry. The responses of total employment, unemployment, or not-in-the-labor force to import exposure would have been significantly smaller if housing prices had not responded endogenously. Our analysis builds on the research by Charles, Hurst, and Notowidigdo (Journal of Economic Perspectives, 2016) on the ‘masking’ effect of the housing boom, but we find that the housing market magnified rather than masked the impact of Chinese competition.
JEL Classifications
  • J3 - Wages, Compensation, and Labor Costs
  • F6 - Economic Impacts of Globalization