« Back to Results

Europe

Paper Session

Friday, Jan. 5, 2024 8:00 AM - 10:00 AM (CST)

Grand Hyatt, Seguin B
Hosted By: Cliometric Society
  • Chair: Wouter Ryckbosch, Free University of Brussels

Reactionary Utopia: Political Radicalization and Violence in the Russian Empire

Julia Zimmerman
,
Trinity College Dublin
Theocharis Grigoriadis
,
Free University of Berlin

Abstract

In this paper, we investigate the impact of tsarist repression on political preferences during the Russian Revolution of 1917, utilizing previously unexplored data from the operations of the Okhrana, imperial Russia's secret police, spanning from the late 1880s to the early 1900s. By constructing a measure of local repression intensity, we estimate the influence of surveillance on electoral outcomes during the 1917 Constituent Assembly. We measure political support for the radical left in terms of votes cast for the Bolsheviks and the Socialist Revolutionaries and for the radical right in terms of votes cast for the Liberals and the Kadets. Our key findings are as follows: Firstly, heightened political instability within local communities led to a shift in electoral preferences toward the right side of the political spectrum. Secondly, the escalation of revolutionary activities in society dampened the popularity of both left- and right-wing parties, particularly moderate and conservative-right factions, setting the stage for the Civil War. Thirdly, contrary to common portrayals of the imperial bureaucracy in general and secret police in later decades in particular, the Okhrana displayed greater sophistication and efficiency, utilizing a strategic approach to enhance deterrent and preemptive capabilities. Our results further underscore how top-down repression can contribute to the formation of distinct national identities and their radicalization, as documented by the Okhrana.

American Relief and the Soviet Famine of 1921-22

Natalya Naumenko
,
George Mason University
Andrei Markevich
,
University of Helsinki and New Economic School of Moscow
Volha Charnysh
,
Massachusetts Institute of Technology

Abstract

This paper explores the efficiency of one of the first mass-scale international aid policies - American relief to Soviet Russia suffering from the 1921-22 famine. From archival and published sources, we construct a large novel panel dataset and document several new facts. We show that the famine resulted from the combination of grain requisitions during the War Communism and the severe drought and the resulting harvest failure in 1921. We further show that despite Soviet interference and infrastructural difficulties, the American Relief Administration (ARA) managed to distribute the relief based on the severity of the famine, with provinces that collected smaller harvests receiving more food. As a result, birth cohorts from the time window around the famine were more likely to survive in the provinces where the ARA fed more people. To establish a causal effect of American aid on survival, we rely on the arguably exogenous variation in grain shipments to Soviet ports and the location of the first ARA headquarters in the suffering region. Our analysis shows how effective international aid can be when it is not captured by local elites.

Shipping Times in the Mediterranean since 1760

Gregori Galofre
,
University of Valencia
Eduard Alvarez-Palau
,
Open University of Catalonia
Dan Bogart
,
University of California-Irvine

Abstract

Technological progress during the late 18th century was crucial to the Industrial Revolution, and while the literature has extensively highlighted key areas of improvement, such as cotton spinning, iron making, and the steam engine, other fields have received less attention. This raises the question of whether innovation and the Industrial Revolution spread through other channels beyond the conventional ones. In this paper, we investigate, for the first time, the productivity improvements in shipping and how they occurred in the Mediterranean.

All at Work? Tracing Patterns of Irregular Labour in Industrializing Belgium (1700-1860)

Wouter Ryckbosch
,
Free University of Brussels

Abstract

This paper aims to study the role of irregular or casual labour in the expansion of industrial production in 18th- and 19th-century Belgium. Important questions in economic history crucially hinge on understanding changes in the supply and nature of work during the eighteenth and nineteenth centuries. Anachronistic conceptions of male breadwinners and a reliance on quantifiable census data, have long led historians to focus primarily on adult male occupational titles and wages. In recent decades newer research has shown how important changes occurred also in the informal sphere of unpaid, domestic work carried, as well as in the area of irregular, casual and informal labour carried out by men, women and children alike. Although most historians would now recognize this insight, quantifying the contribution and effect of changes in irregular labour before and during the industrial revolution has proven largely elusive. Drawing on an extensive dataset of thousands of witness depositions recorded between 1700 and 1860, this article seeks to trace changes in the work – both regular and irregular, formal and informal – carried out by women, men and children in Belgium during a period of economic decline and subsequent expansion. Understanding the dynamics of irregular labour in a region where most urban labour remained strongly regulated by guilds, will provide insight into the relationship between industrialisation and the transformation of work, as well as more specifically in the history of the relationship between patriarchal social relations and capitalism.

Discussant(s)
Natalya Naumenko
,
George Mason University
Michael Poyker
,
University of Nottingham
Victor Degorce
,
School for Advanced Studies in the Social Sciences
Meredith Paker
,
Grinnell College
JEL Classifications
  • N3 - Labor and Consumers, Demography, Education, Health, Welfare, Income, Wealth, Religion, and Philanthropy
  • N4 - Government, War, Law, International Relations, and Regulation